Console

A citation that resolves to a different case

Mata v. Avianca order: the reporter cite is real but held by Gibbs v. Maxwell House — the named case does not exist. Only identity checking catches it.

1 citation found, 0 quotes found

  • 1 from cache
  • 0 live lookups
  • 0 live opinion texts fetched (cached bodies not counted)
  • 1 citations with a row below (existence stage ran; identity and quotation are scoped in the readiness box)

Check executed 2026-10-17T11:45:00+00:00 against public-record snapshot fixture-corpus (not the live public corpus) (world frozen then; cases decided after need recheck). Record cb20b3f7205b. A new execution timestamp does not imply newly refreshed evidence.

Record cb20b3f7205b — check executed 2026-10-17T11:45:00+00:00

Public-record snapshot: fixture-corpus (not the live public corpus) (dataset freshness, not execution time)

Snapshot date unverified — treat every row as provisional and recheck once a dated snapshot lands.

A new check timestamp does not imply newly refreshed evidence. Opinion-text retrieval times print per row where quotes were compared.

Brief SHA-256: e7d6d838fdeb9cb2764930878d5b09e2db5de3cf58b256340e791d075cacb6f9

Scannable audit code for this record
Filing readiness. 1 need attention (wrong case: 1); 0 couldn't be checked; 0 verified. Identity checked on 1 of 1 rows; the rest was not name-compared. Quotation compared on 0 of 0 passages. Document outcome: complete.
Show

Needs attention (1)

Citations here are wrong, or right but worth reading yourself.

0 of 1 reviewed

Wrong case (1)

[ CHECK CASE ] 738 F.2d 1153 (11th Cir. 1984) (11th Cir. 1984)

Citation mismatch — reporter or year plausibility does not resolve identity.

Cited case name does not match the case at this citation.

Review class: Fabricated or mismatched citation.

Resolved to Gibbs v. Maxwell House 11th Cir. 1984-08-09

Good law: not checked — open citing history below. Shepardize/KeyCite before filing.

Brief claims

Holliday v. Atl. Capital Corp. (1984)

Public record has

Gibbs v. Maxwell House (1984)

Did you mean Gibbs v. Maxwell House, 738 F.2d 1153 (1984)? Verify before filing.

Appendix: Checking further (next steps, not findings)

738 F.2d 1153 (11th Cir. 1984)

Publication check (consistent): Reporter, volume and year fit the publication history of Federal Reporter, 2d. This is not verification -- the citation still needs a manual check, it just shows no publication-history red flags. Reporter/year plausibility does not resolve case-name identity: an identity mismatch remains a mismatch even when this note is consistent.

Still good law? We don't decide that: the groups below open citing-history searches for the named case, never a verdict. Lexis/Westlaw subscribers: Shepardize or KeyCite the citation there. No free search replaces that check.

This record verifies citation existence and quote accuracy against public court records. It does not verify that cited authority supports the proposition for which it is cited, nor whether the authority remains good law. It does not detect all possible citation errors. Attorney review required under Rule 11.