A citation that resolves to a different case

The reporter location is real and occupied by a real case, but the case named at it does not exist. Existence checking alone passes this; only the identity check catches it.

1 citations found, 0 quotes found

1 from cache
0 live lookups
0 opinion texts fetched
1 citations checked

Data snapshot fixture-corpus (not the live public corpus). Run 2026-10-05T19:50:45+00:00. Record 1acc0b22c96b.

0 Verified
1 Needs attention Jump to section
0 Couldn't check

Needs attention (1)

Citations here are wrong, or right but worth reading yourself.

0 of 1 reviewed

[ CHECK CASE ] Holliday v. Atl. Capital Corp., 738 F.2d 1153 (ca11 1984) FullCaseCitation court hint ca11 year hint 1984

Cited case name does not match the case at this citation.

Resolved to Gibbs v. Maxwell House 11th Cir. 1984-08-09

Still good law? We don't decide that — check what has cited this case since:

Lexis/Westlaw subscribers: Shepardize or KeyCite this citation there. No free search replaces that check.

Brief claims

Holliday v. Atl. Capital Corp. (1984)

Public record has

Gibbs v. Maxwell House (1984)

Publication check (consistent): Reporter, volume and year fit the publication history of Federal Reporter, 2d. This is not verification -- the citation still needs a manual check, it just shows no publication-history red flags.

Mark reviewed

This record verifies citation existence and quote accuracy against public court records. It does not verify that cited authority supports the proposition for which it is cited, nor whether the authority remains good law. It does not detect all possible citation errors. Attorney review required under Rule 11.